Pay In Cash and Get A Deal, Part 2
In
Newsletter #330, I wrote about a trend of several restaurants and retail
stores that are offering a cash discount. Specifically, I mentioned Luigi’s
Trattoria in Framingham MA that was offering a 20% discount to cash
customers.
The
restaurant using this tactic states that 80% to 85% of its customers used to
use credit cards. After offering the discount, the percentage of credit card
users dropped to 20% to 25%.
I
received lots of emails from newsletter readers complaining about the
process with several readers surprised that I would recommend such a tactic.
Read my
lips!!! I never recommended nor do I recommend that any retailer offer a 20%
discount or any cash discount to customers who pay by cash.
I did
say, “Anyhow...the concept is taking off and you may want to think about
it.”
The
information actually came from The National Restaurant Association
SmartBrief Newsletter:
http://www.smartbrief.com/news/nra/storyDetails.jsp?issueid=7B08DB11-A079-42F7-B87B-27ED661D19CB©id=E5040F59-8449-4058-B9EB-3B26DABB77F0&sid=9a375f81-708d-44e5-a5f7-ca5c11478ab7&brief=nra
And a
recent article published by The Detroit Free Press:
http://www.freep.com/article/20090809/COL20/908090346
/1115/ENT05/Pay-with-cash-and-you-could-get-a-meal-deal
More
articles are available by searching Google news for the words RESTAURANT
CASH DISCOUNT.
So here
is my opinion (which has not changed). I would not recommend that any
restaurant offer a cash discount. I think it is an interesting concept to
think about and read about, but I would not recommend it for lots of
reasons.
As I
mentioned in Newsletter #330, it is probably against your merchant agreement
with your credit card processor (but you need to check that out with your
credit card processor). It may be against your local, state or municipality
laws. It may overly alert IRS agents that your restaurant may not be
reporting all of your income.
Any
discounts that you offer to a certain group of customers (cash customers)
may eventually come back to haunt you. Many businesses need to pay by credit
card. Many of your best customers who freely spend money on a credit card
may not be too happy that they are actually overpaying compared to cash
customers. Your credit card users will probably start complaining about the
discount and also demand that same discount.
Going
back to the 1950’s, credit card usage was very rare. For better or worse,
credit cards have helped to build the economy and make it much easier for
consumers to make purchases. When I started my business back in 1976, I did
not accept credit cards. All payments needed to be made by cash or check. My
business increased by 75% as soon as I started accepting credit cards. I’m
not sure that it would be easy to go backwards and cease credit card
acceptance.
Having
a 20% off sale makes it difficult to go back. A high percentage of people
only buy from department stores when they have a sale. People wait for
holiday sales before buying many items. Car dealerships have offered $4,500
cash for clunker deals. It went over real great, but watch car sales in the
upcoming weeks. If it isn’t on sale, people are not going to buy it.
Once
you offer a 20% cash discount, it is real difficult to turn back. You are
getting your customers to rely on a sale price. Department stores and many
retail stores are now stuck. People don’t buy unless it is on sale.
So no,
I don’t recommend that you offer a 20% discount. It is interesting to read
about. It is interesting to think about, but I don’t think it is a great
idea.
The
best way to get money out of customers is to have great service, great
products, and a good value for the price paid. Starbucks (whether you like
them or not) has the reputation of offering a great cup of coffee and a
unique experience to its customers that are willing to pay a little more
for. Many customers flock to Macy’s to buy name brand shirts at a 25%
discount. Many of those customers end up buying more expensive shirts that
they believe to be superior in quality and that offer a better fashion
statement.
Use
your discounting smartly and sparingly.
Supermarket Valet Parking
Here’s
an interesting article that you may want to read. In order to compete better
with two other local supermarkets, a Shoprite supermarket decided to offer
customers free valet parking.
No one
wants it.
The
local Stop & Shop countered by marketing the value that it gives to its
customers. Do you want value? or do you want someone to park your car?
Read
the interesting little article that shows how some ideas just don’t work:
http://www.silive.com/news/index.ssf/2009/08/staten_island
_supermarket_shop.html
Can Your Trust Free Antivirus Software?
Those
of you who read the newsletter know that I highly recommend Norton Internet
Security 2009 (a Symantec product). I believe that it is the best available
product for the majority of small business owners, home computer owners, and
students. pcAmerica uses Symantec’s corporate edition. It is a great product
for larger businesses. I also acknowledged that FREE AVG is pretty good and
probably 95% as good as Norton.
Many
business owners and newsletter readers use the FREE AVG. As I pointed out,
although you may be using it and not paying for it, small businesses should
be paying for it (at least according to the license agreement).
But,
the question is, is a FREE product such as AVG as good as a paid product
such as Norton Internet Security 2009?
The
question is answered in an article published August 24, 2009 in PC World
Magazine. In short, the FREE products don’t work quite as well as the paid
product. It’s very difficult to define “don’t work quite as well.” I
arbitrarily say that the FREE STUFF is 95% as effective as the PAID STUFF.
Personally, I pay $69 per year for Norton Internet Security 2009. Actually,
I normally get it for FREE by buying it from Staples who offers frequent
upgrade and rebate discounts (about four times per year). I use AVG on one
of my laptops that I use for testing. I haven’t gotten a virus or spyware on
it yet.
Read
the article and make your own decision. Go to:
http://www.pcworld.com/article/170587/can_you_trust_free_antivirus
_software.html
PC
World recommends Avira as the best FREE Antivirus/Antispyware product. AVG
(extremely popular) is ranked #3. Most important is that your computer must
be protected. If you want my opinion, buy Norton Internet Security 2009. If
you don’t want to spend any money, don’t read too many emails, and don’t use
the internet so much, then try one of the FREE products.